Idaho Remarketing LLC

16 North Curtis Road, Boise, ID 83706
4.4
4.4 out of 5 stars

Used 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5i

73,386 miles
For Sale:$9,999
Estimated payment:$227/mo.
$0 trade-in, 10% down payment, 48 months, Great credit score

Value ChartA visual chart indicating the fair price range is between $5,800 and $6,800, while the current price is $9,999.$5,800 - $6,800$9,999
  • Priced at $9,999, this vehicle is $3,199 above the high end of its fair market value of $6,800.

  • The current fair market price range is between $5,800 to $6,800.

  • It has 73,386 miles, which is 76,514 (51%) below the median mileage of 149,900.

Note: This is an estimate based on a variety of factors (experimental feature). It is intended to provide a fair market value range to help guide your buying decision.

View Full Value Report
  • Car
  • Sedan
  • Extended Front Legroom
  • Condition
    Used
  • Mileage
    73,386miles
  • Aggregate Ratings
    3.2
    3.2 out of 5 stars
  • Generation
    4(2005 - 2009)
  • Trim
    2.5i
  • Drivetrain
    All Wheel
  • Transmission
    4-Speed Automatic
  • MPG
    20 city27 highwayMax range: 432 miles
  • Exterior Color
    BLUE
  • Interior Color
    Off Black (Gray)Factory Paint Code:BLA-
  • Upholstery
    Cloth
  • Size Segment
    Subcompact
  • Doors
    4
  • Max Seating
    5
  • Max Towing Capacity
    2,700lbs.
  • Ground Clearance
    5.9inch
  • Final Assembly Point
    Lafayette, Indiana
  • VIN
    4S3BL616357227171
  • Starting MSRP
    $22,020

Engine2.5L H4 Gasoline 168hp

  • Fuel Type:Gasoline
  • Max Horsepower:168 hp @ 5600 rpm
  • Power to Weight Ratio:19.05lbs/hp
  • Max Torque:166 ft.lbf @ 4000 rpm
  • Displacement:2.5liters
  • Block Type:H
  • Cylinders:4
  • Aspiration:Naturally Aspirated
  • Fuel Induction:Fuel Injection
  • Cam Type:SOHC
  • Valves:16

  • Convenience:

    • Automatic Climate Control

  • Air Conditioning

    • Front air conditioning: automatic climate control
    • Front air conditioning zones: single
    • Front air conditioning
  • Airbags

    • Side airbags: front
    • Front airbags: dual
    • Side curtain airbags: front
    • Side curtain airbags: rear
  • Audio System

    • In-Dash CD: single disc
    • Radio: AM/FM
  • Brakes

    • ABS: 4-wheel
  • Convenience Features

    • Steering wheel: tilt
    • Center console: front console with storage
    • Cruise control
    • Power steering
    • Multi-function remote: keyless entry
    • Multi-function remote: trunk release
  • Drivetrain

    • Limited slip differential: center
  • Instrumentation

    • Clock
    • Gauge: tachometer
    • Trip odometer
  • Lights

    • Daytime running lights
  • Mirrors

    • Side mirror adjustments: power
  • Seats

    • Front seat type: bucket
    • Upholstery: cloth
    • Rear seat type: bench
  • Security

    • Anti-theft system: alarm
    • Power door locks
  • Tires and Rims

    • Wheels: aluminum alloy
    • Wheel diameter: 16 inch
  • Windows

    • Front wipers: intermittent
    • Window defogger: rear
    • Power windows

  • S2:

    • Air Pollution Score:9.5
    • Greenhouse Gas Score:7
    • Fuel Type:Gasoline
    • Epa Underhood Id:5FJXX02.5NKR
  • B5:

    • Air Pollution Score:6
    • Greenhouse Gas Score:7
    • Fuel Type:Gasoline
    • Epa Underhood Id:5FJXX02.5MJS

2005 Subaru Legacy Overview

The 2005 Subaru Legacy represents the third generation of Subaru's mid-size sedan and wagon, offering a compelling blend of practicality, Subaru's signature all-wheel-drive capability, and a refined driving experience. For 2005, the Legacy received a significant mid-cycle refresh, bringing updated styling, improved interiors, and a more powerful engine option, solidifying its position as a smart choice for those seeking a capable and reliable all-weather vehicle.

Highlights

  • Engine & Performance:

    • 2.5i (Naturally Aspirated): The standard engine was a 2.5-liter horizontally opposed (boxer) four-cylinder engine. This engine produced approximately 175 horsepower, offering adequate power for daily driving and highway cruising. Its boxer design contributes to a lower center of gravity, enhancing handling.
    • 2.5 GT (Turbocharged): For a more spirited driving experience, the 2.5 GT model featured a turbocharged version of the 2.5-liter boxer engine. This significantly boosted power output to around 250 horsepower, providing brisk acceleration and sporty performance.
    • All-Wheel Drive (AWD): A cornerstone of the Subaru brand, all Legacy models came standard with Subaru's Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system. This system continuously distributes power to all four wheels, offering superior traction and stability in various weather conditions, including rain, snow, and ice.
    • Transmission Options: Buyers could choose between a 5-speed manual transmission or a 4-speed automatic transmission. The manual offered a more engaging driving experience, while the automatic provided convenience.
  • Safety Features:

    • Standard All-Wheel Drive: As mentioned, the standard AWD system is a significant safety advantage, greatly improving stability and control during adverse weather.
    • Antilock Braking System (ABS): Standard on all trims, ABS prevents wheel lock-up during hard braking, allowing the driver to maintain steering control.
    • Front-Seat Side Airbags: These airbags provide enhanced protection for occupants in the event of a side-impact collision.
    • Side Curtain Airbags: Available on some trims, these airbags deploy from the roofline to protect occupants' heads in side impacts and rollovers.
    • Brake Assist: This feature automatically applies additional braking force when it detects emergency braking, helping to shorten stopping distances.
    • Electronic Brakeforce Distribution (EBD): EBD works with ABS to optimize braking pressure between the front and rear wheels based on vehicle load, further improving stopping performance.
  • Summary of Trims:

    • 2.5i: The entry-level model, offering the core Subaru experience with standard AWD and a comfortable interior.
    • 2.5i Premium: Builds upon the 2.5i with added convenience and comfort features like alloy wheels, a power driver's seat, and an upgraded audio system.
    • 2.5 GT: The performance-oriented trim, featuring the turbocharged engine, sport-tuned suspension, larger brakes, and often more aggressive styling cues.
    • 2.5 GT Limited: The top-tier performance model, combining the turbocharged engine with premium features such as leather upholstery, a sunroof, and advanced audio.
  • Other Notable Aspects:

    • Updated Styling: The 2005 refresh brought a more modern and aerodynamic exterior design, including new headlights, taillights, grille, and front/rear fascias.
    • Improved Interior: The cabin received an update with a more refined dashboard layout, higher-quality materials, and a more ergonomic design.
    • Spacious Interior: The Legacy offered a good amount of passenger space for its class, particularly in the rear seats, making it comfortable for families.
    • Cargo Capacity: Both sedan and wagon body styles provided practical cargo space, with the wagon offering significantly more versatility for hauling gear.
    • Comfortable Ride: Despite its capable handling, the Legacy generally provided a comfortable and compliant ride, suitable for long-distance travel.

What to Expect

Owning a 2005 Subaru Legacy typically means experiencing a reliable and practical vehicle, especially if it has been well-maintained. The Subaru boxer engine, while requiring specific maintenance practices, is generally durable.

  • Maintenance: Regular maintenance is key. This includes oil changes with the correct oil viscosity, checking and topping off all fluid levels (coolant, brake fluid, power steering fluid), and inspecting belts and hoses. The timing belt, if equipped with one (check specific engine configuration), is a critical component that needs to be replaced at recommended intervals (typically around 60,000 to 100,000 miles) to prevent catastrophic engine damage. Spark plug replacement, air filter changes, and brake pad/rotor maintenance are also standard. Due to the AWD system, tire rotation is crucial to ensure even wear.

  • Insurance: Insurance costs for a 2005 Subaru Legacy will vary based on factors like your location, driving record, chosen coverage levels, and the specific trim. Generally, AWD vehicles can sometimes have slightly higher insurance premiums due to their perceived accident avoidance capabilities, but this is often offset by Subaru's reputation for reliability. Comprehensive and collision coverage will likely be more expensive than liability-only.

Potential Considerations

While the 2005 Subaru Legacy is a well-regarded vehicle, potential buyers should be aware of a few common issues:

  • Head Gasket Concerns: Certain model years of Subaru vehicles, particularly those with naturally aspirated boxer engines, have been known to experience head gasket leaks. While not all 2005 Legacys will have this problem, it's a common issue to inquire about during purchase. Symptoms include coolant loss, white smoke from the exhaust, or milky oil. Repairing head gaskets can be an expensive undertaking.
  • Rust: Like many vehicles from this era, rust can be a concern, especially in areas with harsh winters and road salt. Inspect the undercarriage, wheel wells, rocker panels, and door bottoms for any signs of corrosion.
  • Suspension Components: Over time, suspension components like ball joints, tie rod ends, and bushings can wear out, leading to noises or a less precise ride.
  • Turbocharger Maintenance (2.5 GT): For the turbocharged 2.5 GT models, proper maintenance of the turbocharger is essential. This includes ensuring regular oil changes with high-quality oil to prevent premature wear and avoiding prolonged idling immediately after hard driving, which can starve the turbo of lubrication.
  • Automatic Transmission Fluid: Regular flushing and replacement of the automatic transmission fluid is recommended to maintain the transmission's longevity.

Overall Summary

The 2005 Subaru Legacy is a competent and capable all-wheel-drive sedan and wagon that offers a great balance of practicality, comfort, and confident handling, particularly in challenging weather conditions. Its refined interior, updated styling for 2005, and the availability of a potent turbocharged engine make it an attractive option for those seeking a reliable daily driver with an emphasis on safety and all-weather capability. Prospective buyers should, however, be mindful of potential head gasket issues and perform thorough inspections to ensure the vehicle has been well-maintained.

0view
Listed on January 30, 2026 (3 months ago)
Not the right one?7 similar vehicles available nationwide
View Similar Vehicles

This Used 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5i is available for drivers in Boise, Nampa, Meridian, Caldwell, Kuna, Eagle, Garden City, Star ...

Cruz™ Disclaimer: Vehicle details shown on this site are provided by sellers or third parties. Cruz™ does not independently verify this information and is not liable for its accuracy. All services and content are offered without any warranty, either expressed or implied. Learn more here.MPG & Max Range: Fuel economy estimates are provided by the EPA and are intended for comparison purposes only. Your actual mileage will vary depending on driving conditions, vehicle condition, and other factors.Price: Prices shown may not include taxes, fees, or other charges. Prices and availability are subject to change without notice. Contact the seller for the most current pricing information.Options & Features: Installed options may not be shown. Contact the seller for more information about available features and options.